Selection maintains floral color polymorphism in scarlet paintbrush, Castilleja coccinea, reflecting combined ecological factors
Fetterly, E., et al.. 2025. American Journal of Botany :e70094
Abstract
Premise Evolutionary theory predicts polymorphism should be rare; however, intraspecific variation in floral color is common and can be attributed to genetic drift, plasticity, or variable selection. Examining floral color polymorphism both within contact zones and across a species' range can reveal the mechanisms maintaining this variation. Here, we used a multistep approach to investigate spatially heterogeneous variation in floral bract color in Castilleja coccinea. Methods We compared frequencies of color morphs, floral morphology, fitness, and genetic structure in regional populations and in a common garden. Next, we examined habitat differences, including edaphic factors, as potential drivers of variation. Lastly, we leveraged herbarium and iNaturalist occurrence data to investigate whether patterns were consistent at the landscape scale. Results Bract color in C. coccinea is genetically heritable, with yellow dominant over red, and is under selection. Populations are predominantly monomorphic, with color distance showing no correlation to genetic or geographic distance, despite significant genetic isolation by distance. Yellow morphs were associated with open wetlands, while red morphs occurred at drier sites with nearby tree cover. Red morphs demonstrated lower fitness in a common garden, suggesting trade-offs associated with pleiotropic effects of floral color. Conclusions Differences in floral color between morphs are consistent with diversification associated with a shift in ecological niche. We identified variation in edaphic and habitat conditions as probable drivers of divergence in floral color. Additionally, variation in other floral traits suggests a combined role of pollinators and habitat differences acting in concert to maintain distinct floral color morphs.
